Sunday, September 26, 2010

Plato/Socrates' hierarchy of truths

Given that Socrates seemss to think that the flash of insight is the most important in the pursuit of absolute truth, do you think that it might not only be necessary to convey the means of achieving knowledge in terms of "stories" before one "knows" something, but also to remind the philosophers of how conveying truth in terms of stories is different once they "know" something? 

Sunday, September 19, 2010

Could the Republic be considered an equal opportunity ( for both sexes) text that is grounded in an ideal society?

Sunday, September 12, 2010

I just wanted to do this for my grade. Is that okay?

I was thinking about Socrates' (Plato's version of Socrates) views of the right of the moral to guide the immoral, and then I thought of Matt Silliman..  I kid.  I thought of the problems that may result from what Socrates (in the republic) considered to be "moral" people governing people who really only saw shadows of themselves on the wall of the cave  (derived from the allegory of the cave, just to be clear) so to speak.  I was wondering what kind of qualities of immoral people would become self-fulling prophecies?  I think there are many, but the one I wanted to think about was if an immoral person was entirely focused on self-gain.  Socrates appears to assume that it is everyone's goal to be moral.  Although his society is ideal, he expands his ideas to defending against the non-ideal  people in his world.   Is it truly the goal of everyone to be moral?  Or is there some motive unforeseen to Socrates, like self-gain?  Feel free to comment or tell me this is a boring question.

Sunday, September 5, 2010

So I was kicking a tree and..... The answer must be logic....

An important but concise question I thought of while reading the philosopher's toolkit was, is logic a necessary component  to meaningful philosophical thought that takes its roots in an imaginative setting.  I mean, I could gather raw and epiphany inducing thoughts from letting my imagination go all over the place, but ultimately, when these thoughts take root in some meaningful way, it is rooted in some logical form.  Anyone disagree / agree?