Sunday, September 12, 2010

I just wanted to do this for my grade. Is that okay?

I was thinking about Socrates' (Plato's version of Socrates) views of the right of the moral to guide the immoral, and then I thought of Matt Silliman..  I kid.  I thought of the problems that may result from what Socrates (in the republic) considered to be "moral" people governing people who really only saw shadows of themselves on the wall of the cave  (derived from the allegory of the cave, just to be clear) so to speak.  I was wondering what kind of qualities of immoral people would become self-fulling prophecies?  I think there are many, but the one I wanted to think about was if an immoral person was entirely focused on self-gain.  Socrates appears to assume that it is everyone's goal to be moral.  Although his society is ideal, he expands his ideas to defending against the non-ideal  people in his world.   Is it truly the goal of everyone to be moral?  Or is there some motive unforeseen to Socrates, like self-gain?  Feel free to comment or tell me this is a boring question.

12 comments:

  1. Re: your post's heading, actually, it's not okay. If you can't work up intrinsic motivation to participate in the work of a philosophy seminar, then really there's no reason to take one. If on the other hand you are merely being flippant, you're entitled of course, but don't be surprised if in response people don't take you seriously.

    With respect to your interesting question, I would question the premise that Socrates thinks everyone seeks to be virtuous. He does think everyone seeks to be happy (or more properly, eudaimonic), and he suspects they are often muddled about how to accomplish that.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This line of questioning actually got me thinking (for the first time in a long time, oddly enough) about the connection between happiness and morality. Besides an underlying feeling of guilt or failure, what unhappiness does immorality (instrinsically) bring? I would normally counter with the opinion that it is the going against one's true nature or harmony that would bring about the discontent, but unfortunately I've met too many people who were innately immoral. This brings me to the question...
    If doing the moral thing goes against one's nature, is it still moral?
    And what about intention? What if Nate has every intention to cultivate the type of intrinsic motivation it would take to participate in a philosophy seminar, but isn't quite there yet? Should he fake it? Would that be more virtuous?

    ReplyDelete
  3. I believe Glaucon tries to flesh this point out in Book II, where he uses Gyges' Ring as an example that deep down, we are all self-interested creatures. So your question isn't boring, Nate, its just been answered.
    There is little intrinsic disincentive to being selfish. But this brings up questions of where the heart of Morality lies, and think the answer is "not in ours." Evolutionary leanings aside, morality is taught. We feel guilty because we are taught we ought to, not necessarily because we would anyway.
    This reminds me of Kohlberg's Moral Stages of Development.

    Pre-Conventional: At first, children develop their morality through a simple punishment and reward system; what is wrong is what is punished.

    Conventional: Later, they develop a basic social rule system; what is wrong is breaking the rules, despite the inherent morality of those rules.

    Post-Conventional: It is only into adolescence that we can develop our own morality; this is wrong despite laws or common ideas to the contrary.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Socrates isn't talking about happiness in our sense at all, but about eudaimonia, which is famously difficult to translate and which we should discuss in class.

    I'm curious how you know that these people are innately immoral, as opposed to their observable statements and behavior being so.

    The key to your last question seems to me to be the verb 'cultivate.' Suppose I want to be a gardener, but have no talent for it. I would do what gardeners do as well as I can, in hopes that I catch on. I might not succeed the first season, but I wouldn't be faking it, just cultivating the sort of behavior likely to bring it about.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Is it possible to act outside of self-gain?

    ReplyDelete
  6. People act out of all sorts of motives, all of the time. Usually our motives are multiple and mixed. Self-interest is one of many utterly natural sources of human motivation. Thrasymachans, especially since Hobbes, have made something of a religion out of denying this, but the evidence for it is massive, and present in our own experiences daily.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Sure... but when you take any motivation back to its roots, aren't they all coming from a basic desire for self-gain? or at the least, a fear of loss?

    ReplyDelete
  8. It's popular to think so, and of course it's analytic that we are each necessarily at the center of our own lives and choices. This is the grain of truth that gives Hobbes's reductive move its superficial plausibility. When you attempt, however, concretely to analyze much of human behavior (e.g.: parenting) in this way, your reasoning quickly starts to sound like special pleading on behalf of the reductive conclusion to which you are committed ideologically in advance (begging the question).

    One antidote is to pay careful attention to the difference between self-regard, which is normal, healthy, and perhaps inescapable, and selfishness, which is an excessive or misplaced self-regard. If I send money to a relief organization in Pakistan, I may well have many self-regarding motives (I want to feel good about helping, I want to assuage my developed-world guilt, I want to show the Jihadis they're wrong about Americans...), but it is perverse and insulting to deny that among my genuine motives could be a heartfelt empathy for Pakistani flood victims -- which is about their lives and aspirations, not about mine.

    ReplyDelete
  9. That does make sense. Thanks for the explanation.

    ReplyDelete
  10. I just wanted to note, that the purpose of the title was to argue against the point of socrates that I felt requires immoral people to want self-gain. By juxtaposing a philosophy blog next to my title which implied i wanted to do this for self-gain, I had hoped for some to realize (or contemplate) how I in fact do this for the intrinsic motive of knowledge and the forming of it into thoughts that can take hold in my mind a deeper construct of what it is that DOES motivate me.... Which pretty much summarizes the argument I have against socrates assuming the intrinsic motive to know things isn't there in pretty much anyone. As far as to whether the argument against socrates has been adressed in the republic, Socrates admits the possibility of there being philosopher kings while also admitting what appears to be a contradiction in the motives themselves being charactaristic of a true philosopher king.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Wow. That was too subtle for me by half. Can you make this argument of yours direct and explicit, so we can evaluate it?

    ReplyDelete
  12. Well definitely something to go off of in what I was trying to say in the previous argument is that I feel that there is something almost contradictory about philosopher kings / rulers / anyone who claims to have absolute knowledge seeming to be tempted by any wrong or immoral deed. It seems that to become a philosopher king you need to evaluate whether they are suited for that role on the psychological level. If a philosopher king can put the ideas of immoral and moral truths into perspective then I feel THAT is what would make an ideal or "perfect" philosopher king.

    ReplyDelete