Did any of the characters in Plato’s Republic truly learn from the teachings of Socrates, or did the ultimate learning come through self-analysis? Most of the conversations Socrates had in the Republic were with people who were considered to be deeply attached to their own views, and yet their views changed. Was this a result of the nous or was it knowledge bestowed upon them by Socrates himself?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
The way you frame the question, it sounds like Socrates has "teachings" or knowledge to "bestow upon" someone. This is at odds both with his self-confessed ignorance (aporia) and what actually happens in the dialogue. Something subtler than that traditional sort of teaching is going on. If as you say the young men change their attitudes, it doesn't seem to be due to anything Socrates gives them, but rather to something they do together.
ReplyDeleteIts quite possible that Socrates could simply be teaching them to think. The fact that he claims no knowledge just means that questioning the validity of what he says is probably something that Glaucon, and all the rest of the dudes, should do. In fact, a faculty member of St. Mary's reminds me of this fact exactly. Dave Kung pretty much taught FOM in such a way as to claim that he could always be wrong, but that was just part of good practice in learning logic.
ReplyDelete