Sunday, September 26, 2010
Plato/Socrates' hierarchy of truths
Given that Socrates seemss to think that the flash of insight is the most important in the pursuit of absolute truth, do you think that it might not only be necessary to convey the means of achieving knowledge in terms of "stories" before one "knows" something, but also to remind the philosophers of how conveying truth in terms of stories is different once they "know" something?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Great question (though it's not clear that "absolute" truth is necessarily the target here -- Sayre puts the point in terms of what it's most important to know).
ReplyDeleteAre image and narrative merely a crutch which we can discard once we've arrived? Remind me to speak in class a little about parable, metaphor, and the possibility of meaning that we cannot properly reduce to the literal or linear.
It is an interesting question, and one I've had to tackle in another class, Methods of Literary study.
ReplyDeleteFrom a linguists point of view, we will always need narratives to some extent. Stories provide a crucial service of being able to remove us from ourselves. The fourth wall, suspension of disbelief, the very act of characterization, are all used to transport us, the listeners, into the story.
Although a philosopher might disagree on the basis of achieving a form of consciousness already outside ourselves,I believe that even the most lucid philosopher still inhabits a squishy meat sack of a body.
Humans use tools to achieve what they cannot within their limited ability. Narratives are such tools, used to catapult us outside of ourselves, into a higher form of thinking, feeling, and ultimately being. Its why you felt depressed when you walked out of Avatar, knowing you couldn't live on Pandora, but not wanting to believe it.
I don't know what philosophers you've been hanging out with, but personally I don't think I've ever met one who managed to forget s/he was a squishy meat sack. Some are squishier than others. I represent that.
ReplyDeleteWhich reminds me of this fragment from one of my favorite guitarist poets, Peter Mulvey:
Inside the tunnels, the stone tunnels, are the trains
And inside the trains, the steel trains, are the bags of blood and bones
And inside the blood and the bones are the dreams
It really is that simple
It really is that fragile